Monday, November 12, 2007

Pumping heat

Spent the weekend dispensing bon-mots and advice in Harrogate at the Homebuilding & Renovating show, one of six held throughout the UK each year. This year I have been delivering a short lecture on sustainable homebuilding and it has sparked some interesting questions and comments from the audience. However this Sunday it all got a little fiery when someone asked about the difference between air source and ground source heat pumps and whether either made sense for his building project. Rather like the output from these heat pumps, my response was just a little lukewarm.

What I specifically said was that heat pumps don’t make much sense if mains gas is available but that there should be a reasonable payback against oil. “You are doing well if you get a Coefficient of Performance of more than 3.0,” I said. I have been consistently saying this for some time now and at least one heat pump manufacturer, Kensa, seem happy to agree with me.

But up stands this man in the audience who said that heat pumps could now deliver over 6.0 — i.e. twice as much heat output for the power input. Before I could stop myself, I blurted out “That’s rubbish.” It obviously hit a nerve, because he stood up and started getting shirty with me. “What do I know about it” sort of stuff. I have no idea who he was but can only guess he was working for one of the many heat pump suppliers exhibiting at the show.

This made me go all defensive and I started quoting a couple of studies back at him that showed that heat pumps often don’t deliver what manufacturers claim. If only to prove that I do know something about it, if not exactly ranking at world expert status. This of course made matters worse and our man turns around and walks out of the seminar theatre in an act of brazen defiance.

You could have heard a pin drop. Normally, these events pass by without any rancour at all and everything is sweetness and light from start to finish. Here there was a definite feeling that someone thought I that I was being out of order and should be upbraided.

What I think this shows is that the heat pump market is maturing fast, perhaps a little too fast. By all means consider the merits of using a heat pump, but don’t get sucked in by the hype, and beware claims of extraordinary efficiencies achieved.

16 Comments:

Anonymous archie@rosewell.co.uk said...

Mark, I have been arguing this very point for the past five years - particularly if natural gas is available for space and water heating (which it was in the case of my own self build). And that's from an economic point of view.

However, I've had a growing sense that there is a stronger environmental argument against GSHP, especially if nat. gas is an option. Taking a (generous) COP of 3.0 then there's a lot of electricity required for this operation to work and this electricity will be coming from predominantly "dirty" (i.e. coal fired) power stations. And let us not forget how inefficient the transport of this energy is - up to 70% losses down the grid. However, advocates of GSHP argue that if this electricity is puchased on a green tariff (ie produced from renewables) then that's OK. Well, it's not, because there isn't enough renewable electricity to go round, and there won't be for a long time, even if the industry adheres to the Government's target of an extra 1% p.a.

Electricity is essential for things like lighting and appliances such as fridges, freezers, TV's, computers etc where there is no alternative. To use precious renewable generated electricity for any form of heating (space or water) is sinful but to use it where there is an alternative (i.e. natural gas or solar) is unspeakable, and for the government to be encouraging this through the provision of grants is quite inexplicable.

If we analyse a the heating requirements of a house on purely CO2 emissions (taking the big picture - right back to the source, i.e. the power station or gas terminal) then the picture becomes somewhat different to the economic assessment. And if CO2 emissions is the big bad bogey then why is there even any discussion about using GSHP (if there's a nat. gas alternative)?

Or am I missing something here?

Archie Hunter

8:29 am  
Blogger Tim Pullen said...

I was there with Mark and witnessed the spat he describes. The point is that any COP is achievable, if the manufacturer chooses to bend the figures. A COP of 4 is a reasonable claim and is not uncommon. But as Archie says, COP is not the whole story. Even at a COP of 4 the carbon emissions of your typical house will increase over gas or oil-fired boilers. Grid electricty has a carbon figure of 0.43kg/kWh compared to 0.25 for oil and 0.19 for natural gas. GSHP is a more efficient use of electricty, but is only zero carbon if you are producing your own electricty.

5:21 pm  
Blogger Mark Brinkley said...

Archie,

I agree with your sentiments, but on a technical pont, I don't think the transmission losses over the grid are usually more than about 8% of the total. The great bulk of the losses occur in the power stations and are released as CO2 there.

In fact, the three big power stations in Yorkshire, which I saw on my way to Harrogate, namely Drax, Egborough and Ferrybridge, are between them responsible for around 20% of the UK's carbon emissions.

6:13 pm  
Blogger Jim Mansfield said...

Guys. Heat Pumps do produce lower CO2 emissions. The figures you quote are reasonable, but you misapply them. You have to divide the emissions figures (which relate to input) by the efficiency of the heat generator, to obtain the emissions per kWh output. For example, with the GSHP heat pump (300% efficient), the figure will be 0.43 divided by 3, which equals 0.143 kgCO2/kWh output. For a gas boiler (let's assume 90% efficient), the figure is 0.19 divided by 0.9, which equals 0.21 kgCO2/kWh output. You can quickly establish that even an air source heat pump with a typical COP of 2.5 will still produce much less CO2 than a gas fired boiler for the same output.

11:14 am  
Blogger Stephen said...

abc test

11:27 am  
Blogger Stephen said...

Please pass this message to Tim Pullen.

Read his article in GreenHomes.

We install many GHSP system, all to reduce CO2.

I could speak to him to set him straight in regard to some of the content in the article.

Dr Stephen Thomas
Technical Director

www.ogi.co.uk

11:36 am  
Blogger lionelmessi10 said...

Obat penyakit gonore kencing nanah Obat kutil pada kelamin pria Obat kencing nanah manjur Obat cairan nanah keluar dari alat kelamin Obat cairan nanah keluar dari alat kelamin Obat ampuh kutil kelamin herbal Obat ambeien yang mujarab Mengapa nanah keluar dari kelamin Mengapa kencing sakit dan keluar cairan nanah

5:37 pm  
Blogger obat herbal said...

Obat kencing Nanah De Nature Obat Herbal obat Kutil Kelamincara mengobati bintik kutil pada kelamin dan cara mengobati menghilangkan kutil dan cara mengobati kutil kelamin dan kelamin keluar nanah dan obat kutil kelamin dan obat kutil kelamin tradisional dan peyakit herpes genital dan infeksi herpes simpleks dan apa penyebab dan bagaimana herspes bisa dan apa penyebab dan bagaimana herspes bisa dan cara pencegahan penularan herpes dan bagaimana penyakit herpes bisa menular yang tentunya sangat berbahaya

10:44 am  
Blogger wasirdenature said...

obat kemaluan keluar nanah obat kemaluan keluar nanah Obat kemaluan keluar nanah penis keluar nanah obat untuk kemaluan yang keluar nanah dan perih saat kencing obat kemaluan keluar cairan nanah dan perih saat kencing penyebab penis keluar nanah penyebab penis keluar nanah penyebab penis keluar nanah penyebab penis keluar nanah penyebab penis keluar nanah penyebab penis keluar nanah penyebab kemaluan laki laki keluar nanah cara mengobati kelamin keluar nanah penyebab alat kelamin pria keluar nanah obat wasir herbal untuk ibu menyusui obat wasir herbal ampuh obat ambeien luar obat alami ambeien eksternal obat wasir cina ampuh penyembuhan wasir alami obat salep wasir di apotik apa obat kemaluan keluar nanah untuk pria obat herbal wasir ambeclear denature obat menyembuhkan kencing perih dan bernanah

2:06 pm  
Blogger arjuna denature said...

Menghilangkan Kutil Di KemaluanSebagai penambahan, diduga hal yang menjadi penyebab munculnya kutil pada uretra pria adalah karena rasa nyeri yang terjadi pada saat buang air kecil. Saat ini juga sudah banyak obat dan perawatan yang dapat dipilih penderita, namun tidak semua dari obat dan perawatan itu dapat efektif menyembuhkan secara total. untuk cara pemesanana silahkan kunjungsitus kami

obat tradisional wasir eksternalWasir adalah pembuluh darah teriritasi dan meradang terletak di anus, sedangkan kanker disebabkan oleh sel-sel yang berkembang biak di luar kendali. untuk cara pemesanana silahkan kunjungartikel selanjutnya

obat kelamin pria keluar nanahPerbedaan yang kedua terletak pada cairan nanah yang dikeluarkan saat buang air kecil. Pasien gonore atau kencing nanah akan mengeluarkan cairan nanah ketika mereka buang air kecil, sedangkan pasien sipilis atau raja singa tidak mengalami hal ini. untuk cara pemesanana silahkan kunjungartikel selanjutnya

obat ambeien yang alamiWasir juga bisa terjadi jika anda mengejan terlalu keras pada saat buang air besar sehingga melukai daerah sekitar bibir anus, apalagi jika tinja yang dikeluarkan berbentuk keras. untuk cara pemesanana silahkan kunjungweb kami

obat kelamin pria keluar nanahRasa sakit pada uretra, sering merasakan desakan untuk buang air kecil, keluarnya nanah melaui penis atau vagina dan nyeri saat buaing air kecil hanyalah gejala-gejala awal yang biasa muncul pada pasien. Ketika keadaan sudah bertambah parah, pasien penyakit ini akan merasakan kesakitan ketika menggerakan sendi mereka, karena penyakit tersebut sudah mulai menyerang sendi-sendi pasien. untuk cara pemesanana silahkan kunjungartikel selanjutnya

Obat Herbal Kutil KelaminMasih berbicara tentang pengobatan penyakit ini, Loop Electrosurgical Prosedur eksisi (LEEP). Ini adalah metode pengobatan kutil kelamin yang menggunakan pisau bedah berbentuk lingkaran dan akan melewati kulit yang sudah terjadi pertumbuhan kutil. untuk cara pemesanana silahkan kunjungartikel kami

Obat Kutil Di Sekitar KemaluanSalah satu pengobatan herbal yang diyakini paling efektif untuk menyembuhkan penyakit ini adalah ekstrak herbal dan minyak esensial. untuk cara pemesanana silahkan kunjungsitus ini

Artikel Lain


http://www.obatkankerherbal.ga/2016/02/obat-penghilang-kutil-di-kelamin.html

9:00 pm  
Blogger Zheng junxai5 said...

zhengjx20160803
coach outlet
jordan 6s
coach factory outlet
louis vuitton handbags
nike roshe run flyknit
coach outlet store online clearances
louis vuitton purses
giuseppe zanotti sandals
michael kors outlet clearance
cheap basketball shoes
ralph lauren sale
supra for sale
adidas running shoes
celine bags
toms wedges
timberland boots
louis vuitton outlet
hollister clothing
coach outlet online
lebron 13 shoes
vans sneakers
timberland outlet
cheap jordans
ralph lauren outlet
pandora charms
cheap ray ban sunglasses
oakley sunglasses
kevin durant 9 shoes
abercrombie and fitch outlet
adidas superstar trainers
oakley sunglasses
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet clearance
kd 7 shoes
tods sale
coach outlet clearance
louis vuitton purses
ralph lauren clearance outlet
polp ralph lauren
north face jackets

2:09 am  
Blogger John said...

longchamp bags
true religion outlet store
sac louis vuitton
coach factory outlet online
longchamp handbags
coach factory outlet
kd shoes
coach outlet store online
michael kors handbags
air max
2017224yuanyuan

11:59 am  
Blogger 林磊 said...

20170708 leilei3915
ralph lauren uk
pandora charms
oakley sunglasses wholesale
oakley sunglasses wholesale
nike shoes
nba jersey
fitflop sale
coach outlet store online
polo ralph lauren outlet online
cheap uggs

2:00 pm  
Blogger 1111141414 said...

asics running shoes
michael kors outlet online
adidas stan smith
adidas outlet
michael kors outlet
longchamp handbags
yeezy sneakers
ferragamo belt
led light up shoes
pandora jewelry

10:01 am  
Blogger Thu Lê said...

I was very impressed by this post, this site has always been pleasant news. Thank you very much for such an interesting post. Keep working, great job! In my free time, I like play game: mutilateadoll2game.com. What about you?

9:19 am  
Blogger Teresa Hamilton said...

It's nice to know the information. Thank you for sharing.
instagram online

10:06 am  

Post a Comment

<< Home