Friday, August 19, 2005

What's Belgium got to teach us about housebuilding?


To British students of modern manufacturing methods, Danilith are known (if they are known at all) as the Belgian housebuilders with the robot bricklayers. But that is only a small part of the story. For Danilith is a vertically integrated housebuilder of the type that just doesn’t exist in the UK. They are a family business that has been running since the 1920s and they own a large plant in Wortegem, which they use to build as much of their houses as they possibly can. Not only do they prefabricate wall, floor and roof panels, but they make their own joinery as well. They employ 260 people, use very few subcontractors and they undertake around 250 projects a year, mostly individual homes in Belgium and Holland, mostly fully finished.

Let’s just consider this last sentence. 250 houses built each year by 260 people. That, in itself, is remarkable. No one at Danilith works more than an 1800hour year if they can help it — Belgian overtime is very heavily taxed so there is an incentive to stick to the contracted hours. Of these 260 employees, just 30 work in the factory, another 100 on site erecting and finishing the houses and the remainder in various admin roles. So essentially, 130 workers are building over 200 houses each year. That’s just under 1200 hours labour going into each house. In comparison, the standard British site-built home takes 3000 hours to construct. Danilith workers are thus over twice as productive as their UK equivalents.

This is reflected in the prices charged for Danilith’s homes. Their brochure shows that the selling price is almost always under €1,000 per sq m (£690/m2). But in Belgium, new homes attract VAT at 21%, which is included in this figure. It also includes 4% taken for design fees and a mandatory 1% fee payable to a private security firm to oversee the construction sites. The net sales price is in fact just €800 per sq m (£550/m2). It’s difficult to see something of equivalent quality in the UK costing less than £900 per sq m. In fact most MMC advocates say that you can’t build at less than £1,000 per sq m unless you are constructing identikit houses in long production runs. But Danilith’s homes are all different, although the elements used to put them together are modular.

In so doing, Danilith produce a very high quality house. We are used to seeing timber and steel framed houses built in factories but Danilith work mostly with brick and concrete, reflecting the prevailing preferences in the Benelux countries and France. The 10metre-long wall panels passing through the Danilith plant are not unique: in Germany, basements are commonly constructed with prefabricated walls. But Danilith have added to this a robotic brick laying machine which first slices the bricks in two lengthwise and then lays them face down on a flat bed, against some retardant paper. Mortar is subsequently brushed into the joints from above before three more layers, concrete, polyisocyanurate insulation board and lightweight concrete are added to the beds, the whole process taking around four days to cure and the final wall thickness being around 250mm. Finally, the walls are hoisted vertically, to be finished by hand on the last of the production lines. Windows, doors, electrical channels and plumbing runs are all set into the walls as they are being constructed. You can view the 15 stage process on the website www.milbank-danilith.co.uk. Floor panels are constructed elsewhere in the plant. Roughly a house a day passes through the plant: on a traditional British building site this would represent the efforts of around 600 hours work. In the Danilith factory, it’s 25 workers on an 8-hour shift: 200 hours. Plus, of course, a lot of investment in machinery and forty years worth of know-how.

The technology used by Danilith is far from hi-tech. It’s the sort of thing that is used on production lines across the globe. Parts of the process are still carried out by hand and compared to the latest robot car builders it all looks a little primitive. And there are many other smallish housebuilding businesses in Germany and Scandinavia using similar finished-panel systems. However, in the UK, the nearest we come to factory production in housing are the numerous timber frame companies who semi-fabricate wall and floor panels, sometimes referred to as open panel building. This requires insulation, services and finishing on site, both internally and externally.

Danilith see themselves as custom homebuilders first and foremost. Although they make windows and staircases, as well as the wall panels, they don’t sell them to third parties; they only supply their own projects. However, they do undertake a little spec. building from time to time but usually to fill gaps in the production schedule that would otherwise have them laying off staff. This is quite revealing in itself. It’s frankly hard to imagine a British firm adopting such an attitude. Indeed, it’s just the sort of action that shows the gulf between Anglo-Saxon and Continental business practice. Whilst we are busy cutting costs and growing market share, the Belgians are putting the interests of their workforce first and foremost. Whilst many British economists would highlight Danilith’s working practices as being a prime example of Eurozone featherbedding, they would also have to admit that it’s resulted in productivity levels which we in the UK can only aspire to some time in the not-so-near future. The Belgians are clearly doing something right.

This remarkable company would like to transfer some of its know-how to Britain. They have found a willing partner in Milbank, who, like Danilith, area a family-run company with a keen interest in masonry prefabrication. Milbank are big in precast flooring in South East England and have slowly grown their business to embrace haulage and joinery. But they are not housebuilders. Both Milbank and Danilith are keen to start building homes in the UK but there are significant obstacles to overcome in order to establish a British version of Danilith.

Perhaps the biggest problem is that there simply is no tradition of custom home building in the UK. On most of the continent, custom home building is the principal route by which detached houses are built. Individuals buy plots — relatively cheaply — and commission a new house to be built on them, without spending a great deal of time working on the project themselves. In Britain, the new homes market is dominated by speculative builders who build solely for sale: there are around 15,000 individual homes built each year but most of these are taken on on a semi-DIY basis with the selfbuilders acting as their own contractors. The burgeoning timber frame sector prefers to offer a water-tight shell option and lets the selfbuilders finish the houses off in their own time. One or two Continental companies offer a full-build service, notably Huf Haus and the Swedish House Company, but they only account for a tiny number of new homes each year, probably under 100 in total.

Typical of Continental custom homebuilders, Danilith is set up to build one-offs. Everything in the Danilith system is modular but provided the design fits the modules, almost any design can be built. They don’t aim to achieve economies of scale by mass production: their goal is to simplify everything down to a set number of options and to avoid prototyping. That way they avoid mistakes and they keep costs to a minimum, without becoming too repetitive.

Quite why the major British housebuilders have failed to take up factory-building Danilith-style is a mystery. Their pattern book approach to housebuilding, combined with the guaranteed volumes, ought to lend itself to prefabrication. But for some reason vertical integration has never appealed to British builders and no one has ever seen fit to try. The only plc housebuilder to currently use a significant input of prefabrication is Westbury, who have built the largest timber frame plant in Europe (Space 4) to supply some of their new homes. But Space 4 is a long way short of what the likes of Danilith and Huf Haus do.

The big question is this. Can the cost savings shown by Danilith be achieved simply by copying the technology or is the different business culture an essential part of the mix? Whilst it ought to be easy to introduce robot bricklayers, it will be much harder to integrate the Continental work ethic needed to keep the robots ticking over. Mark Brinkley

Labels: ,

5 Comments:

Blogger jaybee said...

Interesting blog. I enjoyed your site and will be back again! I spend much spare time surfing.
I'm on the net Wedding Photography Northampton UK. It pretty much covers local Wedding Photography Northampton UK related stuff.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)

1:34 pm  
Blogger Mark said...

Wandering the Blog "Library"
One of the things that I like about reading blogs is the same thing that I have always liked about wandering around a library.
Hi, I was just blog surfing and found you and i like your blog! If you like, go see my indy mac related site. You may still find something of interest.

1:57 pm  
Blogger Michael Powell said...

Well said, not only are builders here in the Dark Ages with regard to design, but their production methods are also staight out of the wattle and daub era.

When I took a tour of a school of architecture builing lab before starting college they told us that they were experimenting with prefabricated brick panels. This was because brick-laying on site was a dying trade, and that within twenty years it might well be finished.

That was in 1967.

Builders toyed with timber framing, but incompetently, and it got a bad name. I know its creeping back in, but not as rapidly as it should. They do prefer to stick with the old, unsuccessful ways.

It reminds me of the motor industry, letting everyone else get on with innovation, then surprised that others could sell thir products here more successfully.

The only thing that has stopper the same happening with buildng is that importing a building means it has to be lightweight and therefore to new-fangled for the UK consumer, steeped in the love of the worst that we can offer.

Still, time will tell.

8:59 am  
Anonymous thck as a brick said...

.comwe have robots serving us in the supermarket which usualy need a real person looking after them when they go wrong i do believe our methods of constructoin are dated and who can stand in the way of progress at the moment no bricklayers can afford the mortgage of the averadge house in the uk and construction in the uk provides a great deal of employment across a vast range trades managment and materials production ,how many of these prefabricated properties will be around in say the next say 100 years there desighn cappabilities have yet to stand the test ot time and if the hundeds of thousands of tradesmen in this country were to be replaced with the consruction methods used in belgum this would also have a huge effect in our economy people in work spend money cars houses holidays ect they are not drawinig on the benifits system therfore paying nicome taxes and keeping the economy boyent in some respects yes i agree our methods of construction are dated but who will be buying these production line house are they going that cheap? carry on with our dinosourmethds of construction and keep britain working steve brickie

11:21 am  
Blogger sam said...

Dear Sir,

We are a SIP supplier from China. SIP stands for Structured Insulated Panels used for walls or partitions in house construction. Previously, people use OSB or Plywood as the sheathings and PUR or EPS/XPS as the core. But now, for environmental concerns, MgO boards are regarded as the best substitute for wood materials.

MgO board is made of magnesite oxide and magnesite chloride and fiberglass mesh, etc. It has many advantages over other drywalls in terms of light weight, durability, fire resistance, anti impact property, and better performance in humid places.

We also supply constructional machinery for making Structure Insulated Panels. They make good quality and endurable wall units and wall parts by using updated technology.

If you are interested in these, please let me know.

I look forward to your thought.

Best regards,
Sam Shan
Sino-Euro Trading
http://samshancn.diytrade.com
samshancn@hotmail.com

11:05 am  

Post a Comment

<< Home